Tags
Take a Break from the Bleachers: 10 Reasons NOT to Watch Practice
Confession: I am a recovered bleacher creature.
When my kids were little, I loved to watch my daughters’ dance classes and gymnastics classes. Too much so.
Sure, I rationalized my (over) involvement by telling myself that it was to far to drive home (it wasn’t), that I was just being supportive (that did not require sitting through every last practice) or that I didn’t have anything better to do (really?).
But what I really wanted was to be a part of watching them grow and achieve. Is there anything wrong with that?
Not on the surface. But digging deeper I understood that I was not the only person in the equation. My daughters’ needs and those of their instructors and coaches mattered as well. And my constant presence was neither necessary nor effective in them growing into independent people. Plus, I was inadvertently robbing them of enjoying their activities for themselves and from developing a strong relationship with the professionals who were teaching them.
Fortunately for my relationship with kids and their own development, my daughters had the confidence to put the kibosh on my hawk-like behavior. I believe the conversation went something like: “Stop watching practice all the time. It’s annoying.” And, while it hurt my feelings in the short term, I am glad that they spoke up, and I am glad that I listened.
Now that I am on the other side of the gym wall, I fully understand why it is important not to watch every moment of practice. Absolutely I encourage parents to come and watch practice from time to time as it gives them a glimpse into their child’s progress and how they spend their after school free time.
But just as you would not sit in your child’s classroom and watch every instructional moment, I discourage you from watching every possible moment of practice.
Here is my short list as to why:
1. It’s like watching paint dry. When you view all practices it is difficult to view the progress in your child. In turn, that can create frustration on your part, which your child will undoubtedly pick up on. Yes, it really can take 50,000 attempts before your child finally performs a skill and that is okay—but you watching each of those attempts might drive you both insane.
2. It makes it harder to see your child’s progress. You tend not to notice that your child has grown. But the dear Aunt who only sees your child once a month notices it immediately. If you watch practice all the time, you will not appreciate your child’s improvement and will not be able to lend perspective to her when she is frustrated with what she perceives as a lack of progress.
3. It disrupts the teaching process. I see it all the time. The child who finishes a routine and looks first to the observation deck for feedback instead of her coach. Not that parents cannot learn to be great coaches, but my money is on the credentials of the coaches who have gone through extensive training and have years of experience.
4. It leads you to believe that you know more about the sport than you probably do. I watch basketball avidly. The number of hours I spend watching games and reading about the sport is borderline embarrassing. I have a good (perhaps even superior) knowledge of the rules of the game and lots of opinions on who my team should draft and trade for and recommendations regarding the starting line up. That said, am I qualified to be a paid professional basketball coach? Should I give the general manager my recommendations? No, no I should not. You get the idea.
5. It sends a message to the coaches that you are not confident in their ability. Watching every moment of practice has a micro-managing feel to it. This undermines the confidence of your child’s coaches who wonder if you think that they are not capable of doing their job.
6. It messes with your child’s intrinsic motivation. We put our kids in sports like gymnastics because they have a natural interest and drive to be in the sport. That intrinsic motivation is essential to helping create happy adults. Psychologists call it “flow” that wonderful feeling of being able to work at something for hours not realizing how much time has gone by. When we insert ourselves too much into our child’s play (and this should be play for them), we break that flow. Of course we want to be supportive of our child’s passion, but we don’t want to take it over. (Hint: if you know everyone’s floor routines, you are watching too much!)
7. It makes it more difficult for your child to make a free choice about continuing in the sport. If you are so enmeshed in your child’s gymnastics experience it makes it much more painful for your child to tell you that she no longer wants to do the sport because now she feels that she is robbing you of your experience.
8. It creates an unhealthy dependency in your child. Independent practice helps to create independent children. Your child forgot her grips? If you are there it becomes your problem too—if not, she has to solve the problem herself. There are plenty of kind, caring coaches and administrators at the gym that will help your child if she is need, let her learn to ask.
9. It’s annoying. At least that’s what my kids told me. And I suspect they are right.
10. It’s bad for your health. Sitting is the new smoking. True story. The more your sit, the earlier you will die. No matter what your fitness level might be. Besides, the bleachers or chairs at the gym cannot be that comfortable. (Secret: That’s for a reason.)
By all means, watch some practice. It shows your child you are interested and supportive. But step out of the observation area and get on with your day. There is a whole wide world out there of interesting things to see and do—far more interesting than watching Susie try her kip for the 10,341st time.
Or at least go down to the front desk and see if they need help alphabetizing their files. I am sure that they will be grateful for the free labor!
Step away from the window. It is better for everyone.
(Note: My next blog is on when you should stay and watch practice.)
Anne, you are amazing! I love your blog’s and forward them to our parents all the time.
Also, my husband and I visited your facility on the Thursday after the Cal Elite Summit. You have a wonderful gym and a GREAT staff. The staff that gave us a tour was awesome. I wish I could remember his name.
Anyway, thanks again for all you do for gymnastics and gym owners in general.
Linda Bennett
Sun Country Sports
Gainesville Fl
LikeLike
Blushing…thanks Linda! I believe it was Jared who toured you and he enjoyed meeting you both as well! I adore my staff–they make me look way more competent than I actually am everyday.
LikeLike
Thank you for writing this article and your blog in general. I find it very helpful in educating, fellow coaches, gymnasts and parents. Thank you for this tool!
DG
Sent from my iPhone
>
LikeLike
Thanks Daniel! You are such a great and caring coach and I am glad that I get to be a part of your professional development because I know that you are doing good things for kids!
LikeLike
I love the way this blog helps to set expectations for parents. Wish I could “gently” advise some parents to follow it.
LikeLike
Reblogged this on Get Psyched! and commented:
This goes for every sport.
LikeLike
Cheer moms….all the time.
LikeLike
I can see staying if the class is 45 minutes or an hour long and your child might need bathroom help (if necessary). Once the athlete graduates to longer lessons, they do not need you there all of the time. I also find that the parents who stay tend to be very critical and negative of practically everything (gym related or not). I really don’t need to introduce that extra drama and stress into my life.
LikeLike
Excellent point, Sandy! If it’s just a weekly lesson that is so short that it does not make sense to leave or if the child is so young that assistance might be needed (and hopefully that child is only in a 60 minute or less class) then that is a different story all together. And it is a really great point about the negativity as well. That has often been my experience. It also has been my experience that the kids of those parents end up leaving the sport before they get to high school because they are so stressed out by gymnastics.
LikeLike
Great article!! Thanks for posting.
LikeLike
Thanks for the blog post. It is very insightful. I agree with some points but as the parent who does sit on the other side of the window, pretty much everyday for 16 hours a week, I have to say that I’m there for the following reasons and I’m not sure it’s a bad tthing.
1. Sitting there has actually created an even stronger bond between my daughter and I. We sometimes sit over a cup of hot chocolate when we gett home from practice and she tells me about her night at the gym and tells me she is happy I stay because she can share that wwith me. Sure, that may change in the future, but for now, she loves and feels proud that I give her that time in my day and take tthe time to sit there and be a part of her world at that moment.
2. I agree that she turns to the window where I am sitting when she masters a skill, but when she turns to me, she is making me a part of her excitment and the smile she has because she is so proud of herself is priceless.
3. As a parent, seeing her progress is amazing. Seeing her dedication to something at age 9 is admirable. Watching her practice has made me see how dedicated she can be – and it’s important.
What I do in 16 hours?
With today’s hectic lifestyle…believe it or not, it is actually my down time. I look forward to going to the gym and sitting at the window. I have gotten to know a few parents and we’ve become ggod friends. Actually, they are the only group of parents who don’t think I’m crazy that my daughter eats and sleeps gymnastics – all other parents thhink Im nutts for letting her train that much, so its nice to hand out with like-minded gymnastics crazies (lol)
I have also been fortunate to get to know the staff and they know me and even how i like my tea! It’s like a little family after 6pm at the gym 🙂
What I do teach my daughter?
II teach her that even though I am at the gym, I am not her coach and that they are in charge. They are the experts and I’m just her biggest fan.
LikeLike
Some really good points Laura. And I admit, like most advice, one size does not fit all. And, I know if there came a time Madi didn’t want you there or you felt like it was too much pressure on her, you’d back off. You will like my blog for Thursday which explores when you should sit and watch–so stay tuned!
LikeLike
I agree with Laura…but to each their own. My son likes me to stay. He excitedly tells me if his accomplishments during break. I dont coach from the side, his coach is fantastic but it allows me to share in all the little victories with him. It shows him I care about what he’s doing and taking an interest in his interests…not just dropping and running onward with my busy life. I do leave every once in a while but mostly I stay…for us both….for the binding and because he won’t be wanting me to stay forever.
LikeLike
where is this gym pictured at the top i want it in my life!!! OMG look at all the equipment!!
LikeLike
Hahahha! That’s my gym! JAG Gym in Culver City, CA (Los Angeles) http://www.jaggym.com
LikeLike
Although I agree with many of your points in a perfect world, unfortunately, I now wish that I would have fought for an open door policy for my daughter. Her coach last year yelled at her and her team mates and often put them down. It was bad enough to turn her away from a sport that she loved for many years. Just as a classroom has an open door policy, so a gym should have the same. I wish it wasn’t this way, but unfortunately, parents need to be aware at all times.
LikeLike
I am so sorry about your daughter. I completely agree that and open door policy is essential. My next blog covers when you should watch. So stay tuned for that!
LikeLike
Awesome post and I completely agree with you! While I do not have children myself, many of my friends do, and being new parents, they try so hard to be involved 100 per cent. This includes sitting on the bleachers for EVERY practice or rehearsal. I agree that while it’s great to show your support, too much support can be exhausting for both child and parent!
LikeLike
After 22 years in HS athletics as a Coach, unfortunately I see this far too often presently. Parents trying to vicariously live through their children’s activities. Parents who will not allow their children to enjoy their activities just for the enjoyment of playing the game. With the help of the internet and Google, many believe they know more than their instructors and coaches. It creates a very stressful situation for everyone (Instructors, athletes, and parents). Thanks for the article! There is lots of good information here.
LikeLike
Pingback: “Hey Mom, Can You Stay to Watch My New Routine?”: And 9 Other Times Parents Should Watch Practice | JAG GYM Blog
I’m curious at what age this applies to. What age were your daughters when they spoke up about you watching their practices?
LikeLike
Hi Crystal, They were 8 and 6 at the time. Clearly with very young kids they need a parent nearby during classes. The comments were more directed at those kids who go to practices that are 1.5 hours or greater.
LikeLike
Great post! I love to watch but do so only rarely. As you said sometimes skills take a long time and I come when asked. I do agree though that sometimes watching just to simply ensure your child’s happiness is important. When you train so many hours per week it definitely needs to work.
I enjoy your blog, thanks for the ongoing insight
LikeLike
Thanks for reading!
LikeLike
Pingback: What Was Popular This Year: My Top 10 Blog Posts of 2014 (Plus 5 That I Really Liked but Didn’t Make the Cut) | JAG GYM Blog
I loved this! I’m a coach and parent, it’s very hard to let someone else coach your child! I used to do my daughter’s private lessons, but I just recently let someone else do them because I want to be the parent, not the coach, and it’s starting to drive me crazy. I think I need to leave the gym for a while, but how do you do that when you’re a coach too!
LikeLike
Boy do i understand that! But remember: lots of people can coach your child–you are the only one who can be her mom! Keep up the great work!
LikeLike